Reduce Latency with FFplay for HDMI Encoders | Exvist Support

FAQs: Reduce Latency with FFplay for Encoder

Step-by-Step Guide to Reduce Latency with FFplay

1. Install FFmpeg and FFplay

Ensure that FFmpeg (which includes FFplay) is installed on your system. You can check if it's installed by running:
  1. ffplay -version
If it is not installed, you can download and install FFmpeg from the official site or use a package manager like apt or brew based on your operating system.

2. Open FFplay with RTSP Stream

Start by running FFplay with your RTSP stream URL:
  1. ffplay rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
Replace rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0 with the actual RTSP URL of your video encoder.

3. Adjust Buffer Size

Reduce the default buffer size to minimize delay. Use the -rtsp_transport flag to select the transport protocol (TCP or UDP). UDP typically results in lower latency.
Example command:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
Explanation:
  1. -rtsp_transport udp: Forces UDP transport, which is generally lower latency than TCP.
  2. -fflags nobuffer: Disables buffering to reduce latency.
  3. -analyzeduration 0: Limits the time FFplay spends analyzing the stream, helping to start playback quicker.
  4. -probesize 32: Limits the amount of data used to probe the stream, which also reduces latency.

4. Adjust Video Output Delay

Use the -sync flag to adjust video synchronization. Setting it to video forces FFplay to sync with the video stream, which can help with reducing latency.
Example command:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

5. Reduce Video and Audio Buffering

Disable or minimize audio playback with -vn (no video) or adjust audio buffer sizes using -an (no audio) if audio is not necessary for the test.
Example:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video -an rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

6. Fine-tune Decoding Options

Add options to optimize decoding performance and minimize latency. For instance:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video -an -flags low_delay rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

7. Additional Optimizations (Optional)

You can further tune FFplay by using -x and -y flags to specify the size of the video window, and -framedrop to discard frames if they can't be processed quickly enough:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video -an -framedrop -flags low_delay -x 640 -y 360 rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
Explanation:
  1. -framedrop: Drops frames when the system can't keep up with decoding, reducing buffering.
  2. -x 640 -y 360: Specifies the resolution to play the video, reducing the decoding workload.

Final Command Example

  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -fflags nobuffer -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video -an -framedrop -flags low_delay -x 640 -y 360 rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

8. Monitor Latency

After setting up, monitor the playback to observe the reduction in latency. You can use tools like FFprobe to measure latency in real-time by inspecting stream details.
Example FFprobe command to check the stream’s stats:
  1. ffprobe -v quiet -print_format json -show_streams rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
By using the above commands and tweaking the various flags, you can effectively reduce the latency when testing the RTSP stream from your video encoder.

Step-by-Step Guide to Reduce Latency Further with FFplay

If you’re experiencing increased latency after following the provided instructions, there could be several reasons why that’s happening. Here are some potential causes and ways to address them:

1. Buffering Settings (Incorrect Buffer Adjustment)

The -fflags nobuffer flag is intended to minimize buffering, but in some cases, this can lead to instability or increased latency, especially if the network conditions are not ideal. FFplay may struggle to process frames smoothly without enough buffer, causing additional delays in playback.

Solution: Try adjusting the buffering strategy. Instead of completely disabling buffering, you could use a more conservative buffer setting or remove the -fflags nobuffer flag:

  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

2. RTSP Transport Protocol (UDP vs TCP)

Switching to UDP is typically faster than TCP for RTSP streaming, but it can result in packet loss or jitter under certain network conditions, causing the decoder to delay processing. If the network is not stable, using UDP may inadvertently increase latency as FFplay attempts to compensate for lost or corrupted packets.

Solution: Test with TCP transport and see if latency improves. Use the -rtsp_transport tcp flag to force TCP:
ffplay -rtsp_transport tcp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

3. Frame Dropping

The -framedrop flag tells FFplay to discard frames if it’s not able to decode them in time, which should decrease latency. However, if too many frames are dropped, this can lead to increased delays as FFplay may take longer to recover and resynchronize.

Solution: If frame dropping is excessive, try removing the -framedrop flag or reduce its impact:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
Alternatively, you can try adjusting the -framedrop behavior to see if it helps in reducing lag:
  1. ffplay -framedrop 0 -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

4. Network Conditions and Jitter

The UDP transport may not be ideal in a high-latency or unstable network. UDP doesn't guarantee packet delivery, which can lead to jitter and buffering delays on the client side. Although UDP can reduce latency in perfect network conditions, it often causes more issues when there are network instabilities or congestion.

Solution: Test with a stable and less congested network, or revert to TCP if your network has high jitter or packet loss.

5. Decoder Overload

If the -flags low_delay flag is used along with large video streams or higher resolutions, it might lead to a decoder overload where FFplay tries to decode frames too quickly, which can introduce more processing delays.

Solution: Reduce the resolution of the video to lighten the load on the decoder or turn off low-latency flags if it’s causing issues:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync video -an rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

6. Excessive Analysis and Probing

The flags -analyzeduration 0 and -probesize 32 are intended to limit the amount of time FFplay spends analyzing the stream and the size of the initial packet probe, which should speed up startup. However, if these values are too restrictive, it might force FFplay to operate with incomplete information, leading to synchronization delays or an increased overall latency as it tries to recover from missing data.

Solution: Increase the -analyzeduration and -probesize values slightly to allow FFplay to gather more data during startup without significantly increasing the latency:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 5000000 -probesize 5000000 -sync video rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

7. Video Synchronization Mode

The -sync video flag tells FFplay to sync video frames precisely, which can cause delays when it needs to wait for the next frame. If the encoder's output frame rate does not align well with FFplay's synchronization expectations, this can lead to unnecessary delays.

Solution: You can experiment with syncing to audio or timestamp rather than video:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 -sync audio rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0
Alternatively, removing the -sync flag entirely might help:
  1. ffplay -rtsp_transport udp -analyzeduration 0 -probesize 32 rtsp://192.168.1.120:554/live/1_0

Conclusion:

To reduce latency, experiment with balancing the buffering strategy, transport protocol, and decoding settings. UDP usually offers lower latency but requires a stable network, while TCP might be more reliable if the network quality is inconsistent. Adjusting buffer sizes, probing behavior, and frame dropping settings can also help mitigate excessive latency. Keep testing different configurations to find the optimal setup for your specific use case.

    • Related Articles

    • FAQs: RTSP of Encoder

      What's RTSP stream? RTSP (Real Time Streaming Protocol) is a network control protocol designed for controlling the delivery of multimedia data, such as audio and video, over a network. It enables the smooth transmission of live or pre-recorded audio ...

    • FAQs: Latency Test of Encoder

      Latency Test by RTSP Stream How can we get lower latency via VLC when playing video on your iPad? How can we conduct a latency test between the encoder and decoder? How can we conduct a latency test of codec by playing RTSP stream? Determining the ...

    • FAQs: Preview of Encoder

      H.265 Preview How can I address the issue of "Black Screen"? To address the issue of black screen when trying to preview live video in browsers due to the lack of support for H.265 in Flash, you can consider the following options: Use Alternative ...

    • FAQs: Video of Encoder

      Video: Main Stream/Sub Stream What is the difference between main stream and sub stream, and how should I choose between them? Video settings in encoder typically include two stream types: main stream and sub stream. Main Stream: This stream provides ...

    • FAQs: Audio of Encoder

      Audio Input What are the audio input options available for HDMI encoders? HDMI encoders typically offer three audio input options, it includes: HDMI Audio Input – This allows the encoder to extract audio directly from the HDMI input signal, making it ...